What the Owner Described
The owner described a problem with no clear start date. Over about two weeks the fresh-food side of a side-by-side had drifted warmer. Milk was turning early, lettuce was limp, and a thermometer on the middle shelf read in the high forties. The freezer side still froze ice cream hard. The fridge sat in a 1960s rambler near Kitsap Lake, and she said it had been running almost constantly, with a louder hum than she remembered.

What We Measured
In a side-by-side there is one evaporator coil, in the freezer, and a fan that pushes cold air from it through a channel into the fresh-food side. When the freezer back panel came off, the coil was not a set of fins but a white block. Frost had bridged the gaps completely, so the fan was moving almost no air. The freezer stayed cold because the coil sat right there; the fresh-food side warmed because nothing reached it.
Frost builds on every coil. What keeps it from taking over is a defrost cycle that runs a heater under the coil a few times a day. The meter showed why that had stopped: the heater read as an open circuit, no continuity at all. The defrost thermostat was fine and the control was calling for defrost on schedule, but with the heater open nothing melted. Two weeks is about how long a coil takes to ice over once the heater quits, which matched the owner's timeline.
What Was Written Down and Approved
The written finding named the failed defrost heater and noted that the thermostat and control tested good, so the repair was a single part. The technician explained that the coil would need a full thaw before the new heater went in, which would take some time on site. The owner approved the repair. The heater was in van stock for this model, so there was no part to order and no second visit. She moved the milk to a cooler on the porch while the work went on.
What this case teaches
A refrigerator that warms slowly while its freezer stays cold is almost never a refrigerant problem, which is the thing most owners fear. It is usually airflow, and the most common thing blocking airflow is frost that a defrost part stopped clearing. The timeline is the tell. Sudden failures tend to be electrical or mechanical; a two-week slide is a coil icing over. On older Bremerton side-by-sides this is a routine repair, and catching it early is a matter of noticing the first lukewarm milk.
Why is my freezer cold but my fridge warm?
In most side-by-side and top-freezer models, the fridge has no cooling of its own. It borrows cold air from the freezer through a fan and a channel. If frost buries the coil, the fan has nothing to push and the fridge warms while the freezer stays cold. A failed defrost heater, thermostat or control is the usual cause.
Can I just unplug the fridge for a day to melt the frost?
You can, and it works for a while, because thawing the coil restores airflow. But if the defrost heater has failed the frost comes back in a couple of weeks and you are unplugging it again. A meter check on the heater tells you whether the thaw is a fix or a postponement.
Is a defrost repair worth it on an older side-by-side?
Usually, yes, if the compressor is healthy and the cabinet seals well. The defrost parts are small, commonly stocked on the van, and the repair is done in one visit. We give you a written finding and one written price after diagnosis, before any part goes in, so you can weigh it against replacement.
Everything about our refrigerator & freezer repair → · All case notes →